Balked Landing Surface — Surface for Aircraft Discontinuing Landing: Airport Planning & Safety
Balked Landing / Baulked Landing / Rejected Landing
A balked landing (sometimes baulked landing or rejected landing) occurs when pilots deliberately abort a landing at a late stage—often at or below the decision altitude/height (DA(H)), the minimum descent altitude/height (MDA(H)), or even after the aircraft has touched down. This maneuver is typically required when the approach becomes unstable, a runway incursion occurs, windshear is encountered, or the remaining runway distance is insufficient for a safe stop.
Unlike a standard go-around, which is planned and initiated at higher altitudes, a balked landing can catch the crew at a low-energy state: full flaps, gear down, idle thrust, and possibly with ground spoilers or reversers deployed. The transition from landing to climbing is rapid, demanding precise handling and prompt execution to avoid tailstrikes, aerodynamic stall, or runway excursions.
Where is it used?
- Aircraft performance calculations (especially for certification).
- Runway and approach design in airport master planning.
- Flight crew simulator training.
- Regulatory guidance by ICAO, FAA, EASA, and Transport Canada.
How is it used?
- Incorporated into aerodrome obstacle limitation surfaces.
- Referenced for operational approval and safety management.
- Considered in aircraft flight manuals and approach briefings.
Figure: Schematic of a balked landing, showing the late go-around phase.
Balked Landing Surface: Definition & Purpose
The balked landing surface is a fundamental obstacle limitation surface in modern aerodrome planning. Defined in ICAO Annex 14, EASA CS-ADR-DSN, FAA AC 150/5300-13A, and other regulatory documents, it is an imaginary, sloped plane extending from the runway threshold outward in the missed approach direction.
Its function: To ensure that, should an aircraft abandon landing at a very late stage, it has a clear, obstacle-free path to safely climb away—despite being in a compromised, low-energy state.
Key Features:
- Slope: Typically 2.5% (1 vertical in 40 horizontal).
- Origin: Begins at the runway threshold (sometimes offset for specific approaches).
- Width: 120m at threshold, expanding to 180m at 3,000m for Code F runways (varies by code/authority).
- Length: At least 3,000 meters, but may be longer for certain airports or larger aircraft.
- Permitted Obstacles: Only frangibly mounted, low-mass navigational aids (e.g., approach lights, ILS antennas).
Why is it Critical?
Aircraft executing a balked landing are often slow, heavy, and have less climb performance due to configuration and engine spool-up delay. Any obstacle within this surface could cause catastrophic loss of control or collision, especially in bad weather or low visibility. Regular obstacle surveys and zoning controls are required to keep this surface clear.
Where is it used?
- Aerodrome certification and safety oversight.
- Airport design for precision approach runways.
- Risk assessments for new construction or expansion projects.
How is it used?
- Obstacle survey and removal or frangible mounting of essential airport equipment.
- Zoning and land use restrictions.
- Design parameter in runway/taxiway planning and expansion.
Figure: Balked landing surface geometry (EASA example).
Obstacle Free Zone (OFZ): Relationship to Balked Landing Surface
The Obstacle Free Zone (OFZ) is a protected airspace volume encompassing the approach, landing, and initial climb areas—including the balked landing surface. Its purpose: To ensure no fixed obstacles (except certain frangible NAVAIDs) exist in the most critical zones of aircraft operation—especially during precision approaches and go-arounds.
Key Points:
- The OFZ extends above the inner approach, inner transitional, and balked landing surfaces.
- Dimensions vary by runway category and code, with extra width and length for larger aircraft and precision approaches (Categories I, II, III).
- Regular enforcement and surveys are mandatory; any permanent obstacle may trigger loss of certification or operational restrictions.
Figure: Diagram of OFZ and balked landing surface overlap.
Regulatory & Certification Criteria
ICAO Annex 14
- Mandates the establishment and protection of the balked landing surface and OFZ.
- Standard slope: 2.5%, width and length by runway code.
- Only frangible, low-mass equipment allowed within the surface.
EASA CS-ADR-DSN
- Adopts ICAO parameters.
- Precision approach runways must have protected OFZ and balked landing surface.
- Continuous monitoring and obstacle management required.
FAA AC 150/5300-13A & AC 120-28D
- Defines OFZ and balked landing surface dimensions and operational requirements.
- Obstacle clearance must be maintained for published missed approach and for low-level go-around scenarios.
Transport Canada AC 700-016
- Aligns with ICAO for surface geometry and requirements.
- Emphasizes safety for both engine-inoperative and all-engine cases during baulked landing.
Regulatory Table:
| Authority | Slope | Width at Threshold | Width at End (3,000m) | Length | Exceptions |
|---|
| ICAO | 2.5% | 120m (Code F) | 180m | 3,000m+ | Frangible NAVAIDs |
| EASA | 2.5% | 120m | 180m | 3,000m | Frangible, low-mass equipment |
| FAA | 2.5% | Varies | Varies | Up to 3,000m | Frangible, low-profile equipment |
| Transport Canada | 2.5% | ICAO standards | ICAO standards | ICAO | Same as ICAO |
Geometry of the Balked Landing Surface
The surface is intentionally wide and sloped to reflect real-world aircraft trajectories during baulked landings:
- Origin: Runway threshold (can be offset based on approach).
- Slope: 2.5%.
- Width: 120m at threshold, 180m at 3,000m (Code F); fans outward.
- Length: ≥3,000m, may be longer for terrain or operational needs.
- Protected Zone: Only frangible, low-mass, or essential nav aids permitted.
Practical Implications:
- Any new airport structure—taxiways, roads, buildings—must not penetrate this surface.
- Introduction of large aircraft (A380, B747-8) may require expansion.
- Regular obstacle surveys and land use controls are required for continued certification.
Operational Risks & Safety Considerations
Obstacle Clearance & CFIT
- Controlled Flight Into Terrain (CFIT) is a primary risk if obstacles penetrate the surface.
- Standard approach procedures guarantee clearance only to the missed approach point (MAP); below this, OFZ and the balked landing surface protect the aircraft.
- Aircraft may be slow, heavy, with flaps/gear down and engines at idle.
- Engine spool-up delay can compromise climb performance.
- Improper sequence (e.g., early flap retraction) can lead to stall or tailstrike.
Human Factors
- High workload, ambiguous cues, and time pressure can lead to procedural mistakes.
- Training and clear procedures are essential to mitigate risk.
Mitigation Strategies
For Airport Planners
- Obstacle Management: Regular surveys, removal or frangible mounting of obstacles.
- Land Use Controls: Zoning to prevent construction within protected surfaces.
- Aeronautical Studies: Risk assessment before new aircraft types or construction.
For Flight Operations
- Training: Simulator practice for baulked landing scenarios.
- Briefing: Emphasis on airport-specific go-around risks and procedures.
- Performance Calculation: Ensure climb gradients meet obstacle clearance requirements.
Real-World Incidents & Use Cases
Incident Examples
- A320, Hamburg (2008): Aborted landing after bounce in crosswind; wingtip strike.
- B773, Dubai (2016): Late go-around after long float; loss of thrust, runway collision.
- A306, East Midlands (2011): Go-around with reversers not stowed; insufficient thrust, tailstrike.
Airport Planning Cases
- NLA Operations: Airports introducing A380/B747-8 must expand protected surfaces.
- Runway Expansion: New taxiways/buildings assessed for impact on balked landing surface.
Summary
The balked landing surface is a critical, regulated safety area in airport design. It protects aircraft—and their passengers—during one of the most vulnerable phases of flight: when a landing is discontinued at the last moment. Proper design, maintenance, and operational discipline around this surface are vital for aerodrome certification and for the safety of modern air transport.
Related Terms:
- Go-Around
- Obstacle Limitation Surface (OLS)
- Decision Height (DH)
- Obstacle Free Zone (OFZ)
- Precision Approach
For detailed consultation or assistance with compliance, contact our team
or request a consultation
.